Homemade Rotisserie Chicken Bone Broth in the Slow Cooker-clear broth
Homemade Rotisserie Chicken Bone Broth in the Slow Cooker-clear broth

Creamy Chicken Penne (Garlic Mushroom, 25 Minutes)

1 Shares
0
0
1

There’s a specific kind of creamy pasta I want when I’m craving a white sauce but don’t want to feel heavy afterward. Not Alfredo — that’s a different mood. Not the kind of cream sauce that sits in your stomach for hours.

I want something silky and garlicky that coats every piece of penne without weighing it down, and this creamy chicken penne is the version I make when that craving hits.

The reason it stays light is the sauce base. Instead of heavy cream or cream cheese, this one uses unsweetened soy milk thickened with chicken broth, a little Dijon, and a splash of the starchy pasta water from the pot.

It’s creamy without being rich, and the sauce still clings to the pasta the way a good cream sauce should.

If you want to use whole milk, half-and-half, or heavy cream instead, you can — there’s a swap note below for each one — but the soy milk version is the one I make most often because it’s the version that doesn’t leave me feeling like I need a nap.

The mushrooms are doing a lot of the flavor work. They get seared in a hot skillet until they’re deeply browned on both sides, and that browning is what gives the sauce its umami depth.

Without the mushrooms, the sauce would taste like garlic and milk. With them, it tastes like something that cooked for much longer than 25 minutes.

The rotisserie chicken goes in at the very end, just long enough to heat through, so it stays tender instead of turning stringy.

A squeeze of lemon and a handful of parsley at the end brighten the whole pan and keep the sauce from tasting one-note.

The recipe makes 4 meal prep servings and takes about 10 minutes of prep and 15 minutes of cooking.

It’s the creamy pasta I make when I want something that tastes like a restaurant plate without the heaviness that comes with one.

Why This Recipe Works

Homemade Rotisserie Chicken Bone Broth in the Slow Cooker-clear broth
Homemade Rotisserie Chicken Bone Broth in the Slow Cooker-clear broth

Creamy chicken penne goes wrong in three specific ways: a sauce that’s thin and watery, mushrooms that steam instead of brown, and chicken that dries out. Here’s how this version solves each one.

1. Use Starchy Pasta Water to Emulsify the Sauce

The starchy water from the pasta pot is what binds the broth and the milk into a glossy sauce that clings to the penne. Without it, the sauce stays thin and pools at the bottom of the pan. Add it a splash at a time at the end, and stop when the sauce coats the back of a spoon.

2. Brown the Mushrooms Uninterrupted Before Stirring

Mushrooms are mostly water, and if you stir them constantly they release that water and steam instead of browning. Spread them in an even layer, leave them alone for the first 3 minutes, then stir and cook until the moisture evaporates and the mushrooms are deeply browned. That browning is what gives the sauce its depth.

3. Add the Chicken at the End, Off the Heat

Rotisserie chicken is already cooked. If it simmers in the sauce for too long, it dries out and turns stringy. Add it in the last 2 to 3 minutes, just long enough to heat through, then turn off the heat before you add the lemon and parsley.

Ingredients That Matter

Penne pasta. 8 ounces of dry penne. Regular, high-protein, or whole wheat all work. The penne’s ridges hold the sauce, and the tube shape traps the mushrooms and chicken.

Cooked rotisserie chicken. 2½ cups, chopped into bite-sized pieces, about 12 ounces. Rotisserie chicken is the shortcut that makes this a 25-minute recipe. If you’re using leftover chicken breast, shred it or dice it.

Cremini or white button mushrooms. 8 ounces, sliced ¼-inch thick. Cremini (also called baby bella) have more flavor than white button mushrooms, but both work. Don’t wash them under running water — wipe them with a damp paper towel so they don’t absorb water and steam instead of browning.

Garlic. 4 cloves, finely minced. The garlic goes in after the mushrooms are browned, so it doesn’t burn.

Dried Italian seasoning and red pepper flakes. The Italian seasoning adds herbaceous depth; the red pepper flakes add a subtle warmth that you can skip if you want a milder sauce.

Chicken broth. ¾ cup. The base of the sauce. Low-sodium so you can control the salt level.

Unsweetened soy milk. ¾ cup. The creamy element. Soy milk has the highest protein of the plant milks and it doesn’t split under heat the way some others do. Whole or 2% milk, half-and-half, or heavy cream all work — see the swaps below.

Dijon mustard. 1 teaspoon. It’s invisible flavor-wise, but it helps lock the broth and milk into a glossy emulsion. Don’t skip it.

Nutritional yeast. 1 tablespoon. Adds a savory depth that mimics Parmesan. If you’re not dairy-free, 2 tablespoons of grated Parmesan work just as well.

Reserved pasta water. ½ cup. The emulsifier. The starch in the water is what thickens the sauce and helps it cling to the pasta.

Fresh lemon juice and parsley. 1 teaspoon of lemon juice and 2 tablespoons of chopped parsley, added off the heat. The lemon brightens the rich sauce; the parsley adds freshness and color.

How to Make Creamy Chicken Penne

(See the recipe card below — the steps are identical and the card is the single source of truth.)

Liquid Swap and Thickening Notes

The sauce works with four different liquids, and each one changes the body and the calorie count.

Unsweetened soy milk or whole/2% milk (¾ cup): The lightest and highest-protein option. It relies on the full ¼ to ½ cup of starchy pasta water to emulsify into a silky glaze. Best for meal prep and weeknight dinners.

Half-and-half (½ cup + ¼ cup extra broth): Richer body. Start with just ¼ cup pasta water and add more only if needed. Good for a slightly more indulgent version.

Heavy cream (⅓ cup + ⅓ cup extra broth): Thickens naturally on its own. Add it at the very end and use just 2 to 3 tablespoons of pasta water to loosen. Best for a special occasion or when you want the richest possible sauce.

Tips and Troubleshooting

The sauce is thin and watery. The pasta water was skipped, or the Dijon was left out. Add the pasta water a splash at a time at the end and whisk until the sauce coats the back of a spoon.

The sauce split or curdled. The heat was too high. Keep the sauce at a gentle simmer, never a hard boil, and add the milk after the broth has come down to medium-low.

The mushrooms are pale and soft. They were stirred constantly, or they were wet when they went into the pan. Wipe them dry, spread them in an even layer, and leave them alone for the first 3 minutes.

The chicken is dry and stringy. It cooked too long. Add the rotisserie chicken in the last 2 to 3 minutes, just long enough to heat through.

The pasta is mushy. It was cooked too long, or it sat in the sauce too long. Cook the penne 1 to 2 minutes less than the package directions and finish it in the sauce.

The sauce tastes flat. The lemon juice was skipped, or the salt level is low. The lemon brightens the whole pan, and the sauce needs a real taste-and-adjust at the end.

The garlic burned. It went in with the mushrooms, or the heat was too high. Add the garlic after the mushrooms are browned and stir constantly for 45 to 60 seconds.

The dish is too rich. Too much cream or half-and-half. Use the soy milk or whole milk option — it’s lighter and just as creamy.

Substitutions and Swaps

Rotisserie chicken → cooked chicken breast, thighs, or shrimp. Same quantity. Shrimp cook in 3 to 4 minutes, so add them in the last 3 minutes instead.

Penne → rigatoni, ziti, or fusilli. Same quantity by weight. Any short pasta with ridges works.

Cremini mushrooms → white button, shiitake, or a mix. Same quantity. Shiitake have a deeper, more savory flavor.

Soy milk → whole milk, 2% milk, half-and-half, or heavy cream. See the liquid swap notes above for quantities and pasta water adjustments.

Nutritional yeast → grated Parmesan. 2 tablespoons of Parmesan in place of 1 tablespoon of nutritional yeast. Both add the same savory depth.

For a creamy chicken penne with broccoli version: add 2 cups of broccoli florets to the boiling pasta water in the last 3 minutes. Drain with the pasta and add to the sauce.

For a creamy chicken penne with asparagus version: add 1 bunch of asparagus, cut into 1-inch pieces, to the boiling pasta water in the last 2 minutes.

For a creamy chicken penne pasta with spinach version: stir in 3 cups of baby spinach at the very end, off the heat, and let it wilt for 1 to 2 minutes before serving.

For a creamy chicken penne casserole version: transfer the finished pasta to a buttered baking dish, top with 1 cup of shredded mozzarella and ¼ cup of grated Parmesan, and bake at 375°F for 15 to 20 minutes, until the cheese is golden and bubbling.

For a creamy chicken penne alfredo version: swap the broth for an extra ¾ cup of heavy cream and add ½ cup of grated Parmesan at the end. The sauce will be thicker and richer.

Storage and Reheat

Refrigerate in airtight glass containers for up to 4 days. The pasta absorbs liquid as it chills, so the sauce tightens in the fridge — that’s normal.

Reheat in the microwave: add 1 to 2 tablespoons of water or chicken broth over the pasta before covering, and heat at 70% power for 2 minutes, stirring halfway through. The broth brings the sauce right back to its silky texture.

Reheat in a skillet: warm over medium-low heat with a splash of broth or milk for 3 to 4 minutes, tossing gently until glossy.

Freezing is not recommended — the sauce can separate on thaw and the pasta gets mushy. If you want to freeze it, freeze the sauce base separately and cook the pasta fresh.

Food safety: store leftovers within 2 hours of cooking. Reheat to 165°F before serving.

Yield: 4

Creamy Chicken Penne (Garlic Mushroom)

Transfer to the Slow Cooker
No Ratings

Tender chopped rotisserie chicken and golden-seared mushrooms tossed with penne in a silky garlic-broth and soy milk cream sauce — a 25-minute dinner with 36g of protein per serving.

Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Total Time 25 minutes

Ingredients

Pasta and Protein Base

  • 8 oz dry penne pasta (regular, high-protein, or whole wheat)
  • 2½ cups cooked rotisserie chicken, chopped into bite-sized pieces (about 12 oz)
  • 8 oz cremini or white button mushrooms, sliced ¼-inch thick

Aromatics and Pan Sear

  • 1½ tablespoons olive oil (or avocado oil)
  • 4 cloves garlic, finely minced
  • ½ teaspoon dried Italian seasoning
  • ¼ teaspoon crushed red pepper flakes (optional)
  • ¾ teaspoon kosher salt, divided (plus more for pasta water)
  • ½ teaspoon freshly cracked black pepper

Creamy Sauce Base

  • ¾ cup chicken bone broth (or low-sodium chicken broth)
  • ¾ cup plain, unsweetened soy milk (or swap for whole/2% milk, half-and-half, or heavy cream — see notes)
  • ½ cup reserved starchy pasta water
  • 1 teaspoon Dijon mustard
  • 2 tablespoons grated Parmesan

Fresh Finish

  • 2 tablespoons fresh flat-leaf parsley, finely chopped
  • 1 teaspoon fresh lemon juice

Instructions

  1. Boil the Penne and Reserve Pasta Water: Bring a large pot of salted water to a boil. Cook the penne 1 to 2 minutes less than package directions for firm al dente. Before draining, scoop out ½ cup of the starchy pasta water and set aside, then drain the pasta.
  2. Brown the Mushrooms: While the pasta cooks, heat 1½ tablespoons olive oil in a large deep skillet or Dutch oven over medium-high heat. Add the sliced mushrooms in an even layer with ¼ teaspoon kosher salt. Cook undisturbed 3 minutes, until golden on the bottom, then stir and cook another 3 to 4 minutes, until all moisture evaporates and the mushrooms are deeply browned. Homemade Rotisserie Chicken Bone Broth in the Slow Cooker
  3. Bloom the Garlic and Herbs: Reduce the heat to medium. Add the minced garlic, Italian seasoning, red pepper flakes (if using), and black pepper. Stir constantly 45 to 60 seconds, until fragrant. Do not let the garlic brown.
  4. Build the Creamy Sauce: Pour in the chicken broth, scraping up any browned mushroom bits from the bottom of the pan. Lower the heat to medium-low, then pour in the soy milk (or chosen dairy swap), Dijon mustard, nutritional yeast, and remaining ½ teaspoon salt. Stir smoothly and bring to a gentle simmer — avoid a hard boil so the milk doesn't split. skim off all the foam
  5. Finish the Pasta and Chicken in the Sauce: Add the drained penne, chopped rotisserie chicken, and ¼ cup of the reserved pasta water directly into the skillet. Toss gently and simmer 2 to 3 minutes, until the sauce thickens into a glossy coat that clings to the penne and the chicken is heated through. Add the remaining pasta water a splash at a time if the sauce needs thinning. Homemade Rotisserie Chicken Bone Broth in the Slow Cooker-clear broth
  6. Brighten and Serve: Turn off the heat. Stir in the fresh lemon juice and chopped parsley. Taste and adjust salt and pepper before dividing into bowls.

Notes

Estimated per serving (using soy milk): About 455 calories · 36g protein · 48g carbs · 12g fat · 4g fiber · 540mg sodium

Nutrition varies by pasta, chicken, and milk brands. Verify against your labels.c

Did you make this recipe?

Please leave a comment on the blog or share a photo on Pinterest

Notes

The starchy pasta water is what binds the broth and milk into a glossy sauce that clings to the penne — add it a splash at a time at the end, and stop when the sauce coats the back of a spoon.

Brown the mushrooms uninterrupted for the first 3 minutes so they develop a crust instead of steaming.

Add the rotisserie chicken in the last 2 to 3 minutes, just long enough to heat through. The Dijon mustard is invisible flavor-wise, but it helps lock the broth and milk into a glossy emulsion.

For a richer sauce, see the liquid swap notes: half-and-half (½ cup + ¼ cup extra broth) or heavy cream (⅓ cup + ⅓ cup extra broth) both work, with different amounts of pasta water.

Leftovers keep 4 days in the refrigerator; reheat with a splash of broth or water to bring the sauce back to its silky texture.

Not recommended for freezing. Nutrition is an estimate and varies by pasta, chicken, and milk brands.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can I use a different milk instead of soy milk?
Yes. Whole or 2% milk is the closest swap — same quantity, same method. Half-and-half (½ cup + ¼ cup extra broth) and heavy cream (⅓ cup + ⅓ cup extra broth) also work, but they need less pasta water because they’re thicker. See the liquid swap notes for details.

Can I make this with chicken breast instead of rotisserie chicken?
Yes. Dice or shred cooked chicken breast and add it in the last 2 to 3 minutes to heat through. If you’re starting with raw chicken breast, sear it first, then slice and add it at the end.

Can I add vegetables to this recipe?
Yes. Broccoli, asparagus, and spinach are all good — see the substitutions section for when to add each one. Any vegetable that cooks in 2 to 3 minutes works.

Can I make this ahead for meal prep?
Yes. Store in airtight containers for up to 4 days. The pasta absorbs liquid as it chills, so the sauce tightens in the fridge. Reheat with a splash of broth or water to bring it back to its silky texture.

Can I freeze creamy chicken penne?
Not recommended. The sauce can separate on thaw and the pasta gets mushy. If you want to freeze it, freeze the sauce base separately and cook the pasta fresh.

Is this recipe dairy-free?
The base version with soy milk and nutritional yeast is dairy-free. If you swap in dairy milk, half-and-half, heavy cream, or Parmesan, it’s no longer dairy-free.

Why did my sauce split?
The heat was too high, or the milk went into a hard boil. Keep the sauce at a gentle simmer, and add the milk after the broth has come down to medium-low.

What does the Dijon mustard do?
It’s invisible flavor-wise, but it helps lock the broth and milk into a glossy emulsion. Without it, the sauce can look separated even if it tastes fine.

More Creamy Pasta and Chicken Recipes You’ll Love

Creamy Garlic Parmesan Chicken Pasta — the 25-minute skillet pasta for busy nights.

Skillet Lasagna — all the lasagna flavor in one pan.

Mac and Cheese Recipe — one-pot stovetop mac and cheese.

Pesto Chicken — seared thighs baked with pesto and mozzarella.

15 Easy Chicken Crockpot Recipes for Busy Families — the full collection, organized by night-type.

High-Protein Slow Cooker Dinners — ten weeknight dinners organized by cook time.

Closing

I’ve made this creamy chicken penne more times than I can count, and the two things that changed everything for me were the starchy pasta water and the Dijon mustard. The first batch I made was thin and the sauce didn’t cling — those two ingredients fixed that completely. It’s the pasta I make when I want something that tastes like a restaurant plate but comes together on a weeknight, and it’s the one I meal prep for lunches all week.

If you make the casserole version or add broccoli and asparagus, let me know how it turns out in the comments.


1 Shares
You May Also Like